Calling Bullshit on Penn & Teller’s Bullshit
Somehow – and I really have no idea how this happened since before and after it’s failed to repeat itself – Derek and I were channel-surfing and landed on Penn & Teller’s Bullshit.
Penn & Teller are illusionist comedians, known for their Vegas shows and, apparently, this show.
I must admit, it was very hard not to write “delusional” comedians up there, especially after watching the episode of Bullshit entitled ‘Eat This!’ – in which they examined organic foods, and tried to debunk a lot of the myths related to them. Some of these “myths” included that organic farming is better for the environment, that organic foods are better for you, that organic farming means supporting local farms, and that organic food tastes better.
When it comes to organic foods, I’m a realist. I know that even organic farming techniques have to be smart or they’ll do just as much harm to the environment as conventional farming. I know that organic foods pretty much have the same nutritional value as conventional foods. I know that organic foods don’t always come from local sources (although Derek and I try to stick to local produce as much as possible) and that sometimes they’re backed by larger corporations.
I didn’t start eating organic foods because of the trend, necessarily. I didn’t even start eating them for environmental or social reasons. The whole reason I started eating organic is because of the taste.
My ex’s mom stocks her kitchen with organic products (other than a few items that she uses in Chinese food that simply don’t have organic counterparts), including organic produce. A few summers ago, my ex and I came to live in LA for the summer and stayed in her house, and that was when I was introduced to organic produce – by way of a simple little staple, the apple.
Finding myself a bit peckish, I sliced up one of the organic fuji apples she had on her countertop and popped a piece in my mouth, expecting the same fuji apple taste I’d had for years. But it wasn’t.
Instead, the apple was crisper, sweeter, juicier than any apple I’d had before, and I couldn’t believe it.
Sure, I can hear the skeptics — “yeah right, it was just a good apple that you happened to get.”
Then how do you explain all of the other deliciously tasty, mouthwatering organic apples? And the pears? Peaches? Grapes? Bananas? Oranges?
While watching this particular episode of Bullshit, I started to get noticeably angry. I mean, I’ve tasted for myself several times the difference between an organic piece of produce and a non-organic one. So how is it that during all of their taste tests — which, coincidentally, took place at Glendale’s farmer’s market — seemed to show otherwise?
Then, while researching some of their sources and some of the claims they’d made in the show, I found out that some of Penn & Teller’s experts were actually the biggest bits of bullshit on the show — one of their main “experts” works for a conservative think tank that’s heavily financially backed by a GM food giant.
So is it too much for me to think that maybe they rigged the taste tests as well to prove a point?
Derek and I decided to have our own little taste test. One of his favorite fruits is papaya. I, personally, can’t stand it, but I already knew my own conclusion about organic foods and he was the one who was a tiny bit skeptical about the taste aspect. Anyway, he’s grown up knowing its taste through countless vacations in Hawaii, and he knows the taste of a good one. So, when we were at Whole Foods a couple of days ago and saw both organic and conventional papaya, we knew it was the perfect subject.
He picked out two ripe papayas that were similar in color, firmness, ripeness and cut them up. Then, he closed his eyes and I fed him a piece of each one.
He knew immediately, after tasting one bite of each, which was the better of the two. One had a better, less stringy texture, a brighter flavor and a better sweetness, and it seemed fresher.
Guess which one won.
Let’s just say maybe it’s not too wise to trust a magician. You never know what kind of sleight of hand is going on behind the scenes.
